The Productive State outlined the case for the State to take key public utilities such as water and energy back into ownership. Andy Burnham’s premiership has opened a debate on nationalisation. This debate has been stifled since the 1990s across all the major political parties under the prevailing orthodoxy of private sector provision, for both the people as private individuals but also the state as the provider of public services. Yet that orthodoxy was never based on solid evidence and the arguments, even on the Left, for the failures of the alternative - direct provision by the state - are cliched (for example British Rail) and lack qualitative analysis.
Many of us have a gut feeling that private sector provision costs the State more: the question is how much more? Hence I have identified at least 10 measures that qualify how a private sector product or service could be more expensive than public sector delivery. Based on an average of 2.5% per measure, these 10 measures suggest that 25% extra could be a conservative figure. 25% of £200bn per annum of government contracts represents a £100bn a year saving. With the Chancellor having less than £10bn of fiscal headroom before the bond markets are spooked, an additional £50bn could transform the UK economy by delivering significant increases in departmental investment without the need to tax or borrow more. That investment can push up the key measure, productivity, creating a virtuous circle. If the State can provide some of the goods and services that private individuals and companies consume at a lower cost, what impact could that have on the cost of living or the UK’s competitiveness? Benefits such as these mean that no sector should be considered off limits for state provision.
What then does state provision look like? Again, parallels with post-war style nationalisation don’t work. Back then, there was actually something to nationalise. Now there is nothing. The private sector has exited vast swaths of manufacturing while a more services-dominated economy means that people are far more the asset rather than plant and machinery. Hence a Labour government using state provision has the opportunity to build productive organisations that provide quality from the ground up.
Have we as a party the will to change things or will we fatalistically accept the neoliberal status quo? We should not for the wealth of our nation, the quality of our citizens lives and their safety. Finally, the State's primary duty is to protect its people from those that wish to destroy our way of life and our democracy. That means military and diplomatic power, both hard and soft. Overpriced equipment and services from the private sector means the State gets far less for its money than it could. That means we fail to deter and when war comes, our soldiers and sailors die because they are inadequately equipped and protected. It is our duty to prevent that become the ultimate legacy of Thatcherite neoliberalism.
The 10 Measures ranked in descending order:
1 - Productivity
UK productivity has been declining since the early 2000s and is 20% less than the major OECD nations. UK businesses are the least likely to invest in plant and people, the things that push up productivity. Hence the state pays a high premium for this. Conversely, in the 1970s, the state invested in productivity. It built faster railways, highly automated power stations, car plants and steel works. With investment, the state can provide the goods or services with far higher productivity than the private sector.
2 - Rentalism
Free market capitalism based on competition has been replaced by rentalism, the deliberate creation or acquisition of a tied customer base from which the manufacturer or service provider can then extract rent through premature obsolescence, closed maintenance arrangements or licensing. Premature obsolescence in the Building Energy Controls market alone, a small subset of the construction sector, is set to cost the state £10 billion over the next 40 years in the replacement of equipment that is a long way from the end of its natural life.
PFI contracts are another example of rentalism.
3 - Failure to Innovate.
History demonstrates the state often innovates, both in wartime and peacetime, at scale and pace. Conversely, innovation is often stymied in the Private Sector because it requires money, that element that is either hard to come by or there is huge pressure to distribute to shareholders.
4 - Values Incompatibility – Outcomes versus Profit.
The values of the Private sector are simple: Profit and shareholder payout alongside some empty greenwashing or virtue signalling.
Conversely, the State is there to provide outcomes, from a secure realm to clean streets and much in-between. The state provides services that contribute to these outcomes but as often as not, will want to achieve them, for example, a healthy population, through prevention such as clean air rather than cure.
5 - Quality
Railtrack and Fujitsu are bywords for poor quality that has taken lives. The workmanship within the UK construction industry is appalling.
6 - Contractual Costs
Contractual costs are part of any sub-contracted service and are high for the state because of the often complex goods and services it requires.
7 - Commercial Demarcation
Multiple private sector providers results in poor utilisation of labour, driving immigration.
8 – Fraud
Private sector provision raises the scope for fraud. The MOD, heavily dependent on the private sector, loses £1.5bn of its £65bn budget a year through fraud. That’s 2.3%. Fraud is especially prevalent in the construction industry.
9 - Marketing Premium
Part of every product you buy from the private sector is a marketing premium. Unless that marketing brings you to a genuine innovation, then it is an unnecessary premium.
10 - Strategic Capacity
Private sector supply chains can be opaque whereas the state can protect domestic strategic capabilities such as steel making.
---
Kevin Williams combines a military career with running his own company, Hurtwood Ltd, specialising in innovative energy saving consultancy, electronics and software for the upgrade of Building Management Systems (BMS), this work potentially saving billions of pounds. This activity stems from his core belief that tackling building energy use is a fundamental to achieving the Green Energy Transition and maintaining low energy prices. Further, it is his experience working with a failing private sector beset with rentalism that inspired him to join the Labour party in 2014 and campaign for a return to the sound economics of state provision that prevailed before Thatcherite Neo liberalism. In his military life, Kevin is an experienced, creative and highly regarded Information Warfare planner & instructor, specialising in the area of sub threshold warfare. He is a recent graduate of the reservist Advanced Command and Staff Course and has been putting his new skills in crafting Ministerial Submissions to use in furthering his ideas within the current government.
All blog posts represent the views of the author alone and not necessarily those of Mainstream.